Islanders Overcome Stars in Dramatic Finish

In a thrilling matchup on November 18, 2025, the New York Islanders edged out the Dallas Stars with a final score of 3-2, highlighted by dramatic goals and a contentious overturned call. According to Deadspin, the Islanders jumped to an early lead during a second-period scoring spree, thanks to Calum Ritchie's first goal with the team.

Ritchie scored after a clever setup, one-timing a pass from Anthony Duclair past Stars' goaltender Jake Oettinger. However, Dallas responded quickly, with Jason Robertson equalizing just under two minutes later, marking a back-and-forth game that kept fans on the edge of their seats.

Bo Horvat then put New York ahead 2-1 early in the third period, but his moment of triumph was short-lived. He received a double-minor penalty for high-sticking Oskar Back, which also included a 10-minute misconduct, as reported by Yahoo Sports.

This critical play took Horvat out of the action for the remainder of the game. Despite being down a key player, the Islanders extended their lead when Kyle Palmieri scored a shorthanded goal, putting New York up 3-1.

Palmieri intercepted a loose puck and broke down the ice, faking a pass before firing the puck under Oettinger’s stick. However, the Stars were not done yet. As the game entered its final moments, Robertson scored his second goal of the night, narrowing the gap to 3-2 with just under two minutes left.

With the Stars pulling their goaltender for an extra skater, the intensity ramped up. In a wild finish, Wyatt Johnston appeared to have tied the game with a goal just as time expired. However, following a review, the officials ruled the goal was disallowed due to goaltender interference, as Robertson's collision with Islanders goalie David Rittich was deemed to have impeded his ability to make the save.

This call was pivotal and led to a mix of emotions from both teams, as noted by Lighthouse Hockey. The game concluded amidst chaos, with the Islanders celebrating a hard-fought victory while the Stars faced disappointment.

The win improved the Islanders' record to 5-1-0 on their seven-game road trip, as they head into their next matchup against Detroit. Meanwhile, the Stars, despite showing resilience, saw their five-game winning streak come to an end, leaving them to regroup as they embark on a four-game road trip, starting with a game against the Vancouver Canucks.

The dramatic nature of this contest, marked by key goals and a last-minute overturned call, underscores the intense atmosphere that defines NHL games, making this a memorable encounter for both franchises.