Commanders General Manager Faces Criticism Over Roster Moves

General Manager Adam Peters is facing intense scrutiny from fans and analysts for his recent roster moves that have not yielded the expected results for the Washington Commanders. Following a disappointing season, with the team's performance faltering in Year 2 under Peters' leadership, critical decisions have come under fire.

Notably, the release of Emmanuel Forbes Jr. has raised eyebrows, as he has begun to excel with the Los Angeles Rams, showcasing skills that many believe he had in Washington. Cris Collinsworth highlighted Forbes' impressive resurgence, stating he is playing like a first-round pick, which only amplifies the disappointment among Commanders supporters.

Additionally, Kamren Curl, another former Commander now thriving in Los Angeles, has been lauded as possibly the best tackling safety in the league. Peters' decision to let Curl go, reportedly due to contract demands, has added to the criticism he is receiving.

Fans had anticipated that Curl would remain a part of the new regime's plans, given his strong performances and previous development from a seventh-round pick to a reliable starter. The departure of Curl has left the team scrambling, leading to the signing of Jeremy Chinn and the injury of Will Harris, further complicating the safety position.

The need for a more effective strategy at safety is now evident. Furthermore, Peters' ongoing struggle to find a competent kicker has been a significant misstep, with the Commanders having cycled through nine kickers since he took over in 2024.

The recent addition of Jake Moody came after the release of Matt Gay, who underperformed with a 68.4% success rate on field goals. Peters' decision-making in this area has drawn ire, especially as former kicker Zane Gonzalez has found success with the Atlanta Falcons, hitting all six of his attempts since his departure.

The Commanders' failure to secure a reliable kicker, alongside questionable roster management decisions, has left fans and analysts alike questioning the team's direction under Peters. With the Commanders struggling to establish stability, the implications of these roster moves could have long-lasting effects on the franchise's future.