NFL Rookies Face Challenges as Season Progresses

Rookies in the NFL are facing intense challenges as the season progresses, with standout cases like Abdul Carter of the New York Giants drawing particular attention. According to Deadspin, Carter, the No. 3 overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft, was benched for the second time in three games during a matchup against the New England Patriots on December 1, 2025.

This decision came after he missed the first quarter of the game, which contributed to the Giants falling into a 17-0 deficit early on. The Giants did not specify the reason for the benching, but reports indicated he was late to a meeting, which matched a previous incident where he was also benched for a similar reason.

Interim coach Mike Kafka stated that the decision was made for the betterment of the team and emphasized it was his call, not a reflection on Carter's abilities. "I just would say this: That was my decision to do that," Kafka explained after the game.

Carter himself took responsibility for his actions, acknowledging, "I let my team down. First two drives, I was out. They scored 17 points. I take responsibility for that. I have to do better." Despite being on the bench for critical moments, Carter managed to record his first full sack of the season during the game, bringing his total to 1.5 sacks and 31 tackles over 13 games.

However, this production starkly contrasts with his collegiate performance at Penn State, where he had 12 sacks and 23.5 tackles for loss in his last season. The Giants, struggling at 2-11 after suffering their seventh consecutive loss, are looking to regroup as they head into their bye week.

The Big Lead reported on Carter’s reaction to his benching, noting his candid remarks, "S**t happens," when pressed for details about the situation. Carter’s commitment to improving was evident as he stated, "I got to be out there, I got to do better." Veteran teammate Brian Burns also commented on the situation, indicating that while mistakes are part of being human, accountability is crucial for rookie players like Carter. "At the end of the day, he does have to be a pro, he does have to take accountability, which he did for what happened," Burns noted, expressing support for Carter during this challenging phase of his rookie season.

Overall, Carter’s experience highlights the pressures and adjustments that rookies must navigate in the NFL, illustrating that the transition to professional football is fraught with hurdles, even for highly touted draft picks.