Coaching Decisions Under Scrutiny as Colts Struggle

The Indianapolis Colts are facing increasing scrutiny over coaching decisions as they navigate a challenging stretch in their schedule. Head coach Shane Steichen's trust in kicker Michael Badgley has come under fire following a narrow 20-16 loss to the Houston Texans in Week 13.

Badgley, who replaced Spencer Shrader after the latter's knee injury in Week 3, has struggled, particularly with extra points, missing three so far this season. Despite a solid record on field goals, making 10 of 11 attempts, his inconsistency on extra points has raised concerns about his reliability when it matters most, especially given that his latest miss directly impacted the Colts' ability to compete for the game.

According to Horseshoe Heroes, Steichen has expressed both frustration and support for Badgley, stating, 'Badge knows he's gotta make the PATs. But I love Badge. I love Badge the player. I love Badge the person.' This indicates a complex emotional dynamic, where Steichen wants to support his player but is acutely aware of the cost of missed opportunities in tight games.

As the Colts look at potential alternatives, they are reportedly working out other kickers, including former Saints kicker Blake Grupe, to explore options for improving their kicking game. Steichen's hesitation to definitively replace Badgley stems from the realization that new kickers may not guarantee better performance.

Historically, Badgley has shown promise, converting 94% of his field goals during his rookie season with the Chargers but has not consistently replicated that success, especially with extra points. The Colts' kicking troubles could be exacerbated by injuries on the team, notably the absence of defensive tackle DeForest Buckner, which has left the Colts vulnerable in crucial matchups.

As they prepare for upcoming games, the Colts must consider the implications of their coaching decisions, particularly regarding roster moves and player trust, which could ultimately determine their playoff aspirations.

The Colts are grappling with a pivotal decision that could shape the trajectory of their season, with the potential consequences of missed kicks looming large in critical games ahead.