Matthew Macfadyen's Stellar Performance in 'Death by Lightning'

In the historical miniseries 'Death by Lightning', Matthew Macfadyen delivers an acclaimed performance as Charles Guiteau, the anti-hero who infamously attempted to assassinate President James Garfield in 1881.

According to The Guardian, Macfadyen's portrayal of Guiteau captures the character's essence as a pitiable crank, characterized by a wild-eyed demeanor, a scraggly beard, and a perpetual state of desperation.

The series focuses on Guiteau's quest for recognition, highlighting his failures and delusions as he seeks to become Garfield's trusted acolyte and friend. The review emphasizes that Macfadyen excels at playing losers, a skill honed during his role as Tom Wambsgans in 'Succession', but here he takes it to another level, portraying Guiteau's maniacal joy and tragic despair with equal measure.

His comedic timing shines through as he navigates a series of humiliating rejections, including when he is turned down for a bank loan to fund his ill-conceived newspaper. The show juxtaposes Guiteau's narrative with that of Garfield, played by Michael Shannon, who rises to prominence through a campaign marked by progressive ideals and direct engagement with voters.

However, the series struggles to fully flesh out Garfield's character, which results in a less compelling narrative when compared to the vibrant and tragicomic life of Guiteau. The Guardian notes that while the series offers a tribute to Garfield's extraordinary statesmanship, it is ultimately Guiteau's story that captivates viewers and keeps them engaged.

Macfadyen's performance is described as brilliant, particularly in a pivotal scene where Guiteau's soul-baring moment with Garfield reveals his emptiness. The show's pacing and character development have been critiqued, with some character arcs feeling rushed or underdeveloped, especially those of the female characters.

Yet, it is Macfadyen's portrayal that stands out, ensuring that Guiteau's name will be remembered for his tragic quest for significance. Ultimately, 'Death by Lightning' not only showcases Macfadyen's versatility as an actor but also appeals to audiences interested in historical narratives, delivering a unique blend of humor and tragedy that centers on one of history's more eccentric figures.